Current:Home > NewsJudge allows lawsuit that challenges Idaho’s broad abortion ban to move forward -FundGuru
Judge allows lawsuit that challenges Idaho’s broad abortion ban to move forward
View
Date:2025-04-19 17:08:44
An Idaho judge on Friday denied a request by the state’s top legal chief to throw out a lawsuit seeking to clarify the exemptions tucked inside the state’s broad abortion ban.
Instead, 4th District Judge Jason Scott narrowed the case to focus only on the circumstances where an abortion would be allowed and whether abortion care in emergency situations applies to Idaho’s state constitutional right to enjoy and defend life and the right to secure safety.
Scott’s decision comes just two weeks after a hearing where Idaho’s Attorney General Raul Labrador’s office attempted to dismiss the case spearheaded by four women and several physicians, who filed the case earlier this year.
Similar lawsuits are playing out around the nation, with some of them, like Idaho’s, brought by the Center for Reproductive Rights on behalf of doctors and pregnant people who were denied access to abortions while facing serious pregnancy complications.
According to the Center for Reproductive Rights, Idaho’s Constitution entitles its residents to certain fundamental rights, but a sweeping abortion ban poses a risk to those rights.
Labrador’s office countered that the Idaho Supreme Court has already upheld the state’s abortion bans — thus solving any lingering questions on the matter.
Scott agreed in part with the state attorneys that the state Supreme Court ruled there was no fundamental right to abortion inside the state constitution, but added that the court didn’t reject “every conceivable as applied challenge that might be made in a future case.”
“We’re grateful the court saw through the state’s callous attempt to ignore the pain and suffering their laws are causing Idahoans,” said Gail Deady, a senior staff attorney for the Center for Reproductive Rights. “Now the state of Idaho will be forced to answer to these women in a court of law.”
Meanwhile, the Idaho judge also sided with the attorney general in removing Gov. Brad Little, Labrador, and the Idaho Board of Medicine as named defendants in the lawsuit — leaving the state of Idaho as the only remaining defendant. Scott called the long list of defendants as “redundant,” saying that all three would be subject to whatever is ultimately decided in the lawsuit.
“This is only the beginning of this litigation, but the Attorney General is encouraged by this ruling,” Labrador’s office said in a statement. “He has long held that the named defendants were simply inappropriate, and that our legislatively passed laws do not violate the Idaho Constitution by narrowly limiting abortions or interfering with a doctor’s right to practice medicine.”
The four women named in the case were all denied abortions in Idaho after learning they were pregnant with fetuses that were unlikely to go to term or survive birth, and that the pregnancies also put them at risk of serious medical complications. All four traveled to Oregon or Washington for the procedures.
Idaho has several abortion bans, but notably Idaho lawmakers approved a ban as a trigger law in March of 2020, before the U.S. Supreme Court overturned Roe v. Wade.
At the time, any suggestion that the ban could harm pregnant people was quickly brushed off by the bill’s sponsor, Republican Sen. Todd Lakey, who said during one debate that the health of the mother “weighs less, yes, than the life of the child.”
The trigger ban took effect in 2022. Since then, Idaho’s roster of obstetricians and other pregnancy-related specialists has been shrinking.
veryGood! (44)
Related
- The Grammy nominee you need to hear: Esperanza Spalding
- Jada Pinkett Smith Shares How She Overcame Struggle With Suicidal Ideation
- 2 Guatemalan migrants were shot dead in Mexico near US border. Soldiers believed to be involved
- 'Oh my God, that's a monster!': Alligator gar caught in Texas could set new world records
- Costco membership growth 'robust,' even amid fee increase: What to know about earnings release
- Ariana Madix Emotionally Reacts to Sign From Her Late Dad After DWTS Tribute Performance
- MyPillow CEO Mike Lindell says he's out of money, can't pay lawyers in defamation case
- Chinese carmaker Geely and Malaysia’s Proton consider EV plant in Thailand, Thai prime minister says
- Who's hosting 'Saturday Night Live' tonight? Musical guest, how to watch Dec. 14 episode
- NASA launching Psyche mission to explore metallic asteroid: How to watch the cosmic quest
Ranking
- Pregnant Kylie Kelce Shares Hilarious Question Her Daughter Asked Jason Kelce Amid Rising Fame
- Kenya ends arrangement to swap doctors with Cuba. The deal was unpopular with Kenyan doctors
- Former offensive lineman Mark Schlereth scorches Jerry Jeudy, Denver for 1-4 start
- Former offensive lineman Mark Schlereth scorches Jerry Jeudy, Denver for 1-4 start
- Senate begins final push to expand Social Security benefits for millions of people
- Henry Golding and Wife Liv Lo Welcome Baby No. 2
- Walmart will build a $350M milk plant in south Georgia as the retailer expands dairy supply control
- Americans consume a lot of red meat. Here's why you shouldn't.
Recommendation
Average rate on 30
'The Voice': John Legend nabs 'magical' R&B crooner, irritates Gwen Stefani
Trick-or-treat: Snag yourself a pair of chocolate bar-themed Crocs just in time for Halloween
Man who found bag of cash, claimed finders-keepers, pays back town, criminal charge dropped
SFO's new sensory room helps neurodivergent travelers fight flying jitters
Trick-or-treat: Snag yourself a pair of chocolate bar-themed Crocs just in time for Halloween
2 senior generals purged from Myanmar’s military government are sentenced to life for corruption
The number of US citizens killed in the Israel-Hamas war rises to 22